Cicero

Why you'd want to live in Cicero

The Town of Cicero surrounds the upper portion of Morse Reservoir. The man-made lake covers 1,500 acres with a shoreline of over 32 miles. Considering the fact that over 600 homes are on the water, have water views or access, it is easy to understand why Cicero is Hamilton County’s Recreational and Resort Community. Residents find the town centrally located. Cicero is 35 minutes from Indianapolis, 30 minutes to Kokomo and 20 minutes to Anderson. While most of our residents work in these larger employment centers, they find coming home to Cicero’s less hurried atmosphere a pleasant way to end the workday and to raise a family.

Cicero Market Report

$852,795

AVERAGE PRICE OF 22 HOMES

$2,812,500

AVERAGE PRICE OF 4 MULTI-MILLION DOLLAR HOMES

$293,233

AVERAGE PRICE OF 3 NEWLY BUILT HOMES

$2,200,000

AVERAGE PRICE OF 1 HOMES WITH A POOL

Average Home

Average Price $852,795
Avg Bedrooms 2.86 beds
Avg Bathrooms 2.36 baths

Average Price by Bedrooms

2 bedrooms $291,566
3 bedrooms $325,200
4 bedrooms $574,266
5 bedrooms $1,052,225
Cicero Home Price Trends
  1/2024 12/2023 11/2023 10/2023 9/2023
Total Listings 25 26 27 26 23
Average Price $716,918 $630,747 $598,968 $622,011 $610,983
Avg Price Change +13.66% +5.31% -3.85% +1.80% +5.73%
Median Price $403,091 $376,412 $404,410 $417,141 $387,621
Med Price Change +7.09% -7.44% -3.15% +7.62% +0.80%
Avg Bedrooms 3.18 beds 2.97 beds 2.89 beds 3.03 beds 2.96 beds
Avg Bathrooms 2.84 baths 2.62 baths 2.43 baths 2.53 baths 2.4 baths
Home Price by High School
School Name Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
Hamilton Heights High School 17 $815,805 107 days
Total Homes Average Price Avg Days on Site
All Homes 22 $852,795 104 days
Multi-Million Dollar Homes 4 $2,812,500 127 days
Newly Built Homes 3 $293,233 211 days
Homes with a Pool 1 $2,200,000 75 days